Saturday, November 21, 2026

Favorites of 2026: Opera recordings

This post continues my series on favorite music, movies and books first encountered (but not necessarily first issued) in the past year. Last time it was vocal and instrumental music; this time, my favorite full-length opera recordings of 2026, in roughly chronological order by date of composition.

There was a surprise this year: we're devotees of Baroque music, but of of the five audio and video recordings that I write about, only two are of works written before 1800. One is from the mid-19th century, and the remaining two were composed in the 20th.

Opera before 1800

Jean-Baptiste Lully: Proserpine. Livret by Philippe Quinault; first performance 1680. Soloists and the Choeur de Chambre de Namur with Les Talens Lyriques conducted by Christophe Rousset; recording released 2025.

Cover of Proserpine by Jean-Baptiste Lully conducted by Christophe Rousset

Cover of Proserpine, Château des Versailles Spectacles CVS 187. Image source: Presto Music

When in 1680 Lully and his librettist Philippe Quinault decided to adapt the story of the goddess Proserpina into a tragédie en musique, they had to tread carefully. Quinault had just been restored to royal favor after the disaster of Isis, which he and Lully had produced in 1677. Isis had been interpreted by the French court as an offensive parable about the loves of Jupiter (seen, of course, as Louis XIV); it depicted the jealousy of Juno (seen as Louis' longtime mistress Madame de Montespan) towards his new paramour Io (seen as Louis' new mistress Madame de Ludres). Quinault immediately fell into royal disfavor.

The myth of Proserpina held similar dangers. It starts, as do so many myths, with a conflict among the gods. In Book V of Ovid's Metamorphoses, Venus chides her son Cupid. Love rules the heavens, the earth, and the seas; neither Jupiter nor Neptune has evaded his arrows. But in one realm he is powerless: the Underworld, where Pluto reigns. If it becomes known that Cupid's dominion is not universal, Venus' enemies Minerva, the virgin goddess of wisdom, and Diana, chaste goddess of the hunt, will gain followers. And among their number will be Proserpina, daughter of Jupiter and the harvest-goddess Ceres.

Writing a new opera featuring Venus, who wishes to rule the cosmos through her son Cupid, risked suggesting parallels between the goddess and the Marquise de Maintenon, the governess of Louis' extramarital children. By 1680 Madame de Maintenon had supplanted both Madame de Ludres and Madame de Montespan in Louis' affections. To avoid any risk of offending the king or his latest mistress, Quinault eliminated Venus and Cupid entirely from the opera.

Instead, Pluton (sung on this recording by Olivier Gourdy), seeing Proserpine (Marie Lys) gathering flowers, is "struck with longing," in the words of Allen Mandelbaum's translation of Metamorphoses (Harcourt Brace, 1993), seizes her, and carries her into the Underworld on his chariot. (And yes, since Pluton is the brother of Jupiter, Proserpine is Pluton's niece.)

When the anguished Cérès (Veronique Gens) learns that her daughter has been abducted, she causes the harvest to fail, laying waste to the land. She pleads with Jupiter (David Witczak) to allow her daughter to return. But Proserpine has eaten seven pomegranate seeds in the Underworld, condemning her to remain. So Jupiter strikes a bargain: Proserpine will spend half the year by Pluton's side in the Underworld, and half with her mother, ensuring a fruitful harvest.

In parallel with the story of Proserpine and Pluton, Quinault introduced a secondary couple, the nymph Aréthuse (Ambroisine Bré) and the river-god Alphée (Laurence Kilsby), whose story is linked with that of Proserpina in Metamorphoses. Aréthuse is a favorite of Diana. After hunting one hot day, she comes across a cool, crystal-clear stream. As she bathes in it, her beauty excites the lust of the river-god, Alphée. When he reveals himself, she flees, but he pursues her, and she transforms into a stream. In Metamorphoses, it's implied that Arethusa escapes; in Quinault's version of the myth, after her initial fear the nymph comes to return the river-god's love, as Proserpine comes to return Pluton's. Again, these changes may have been made to avoid any unflattering parallels between the gods and Louis and his mistresses.

This recording is yet another of the superb series of French Baroque works issued over the past decade or so by Château de Versailles Spectacles, featuring the cream of current French singers and ensembles. "Vaine fierte, faible rigeur" from Act I, Scene 4, in which Aréthuse expresses her inner struggle against love:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Voineiq2aTo

Vaine fierté, faible rigueur,
Que vous avez peu de puissance
Contre l'amour et la constance!
Vaine fierté, faible rigueur,
Ah! Que vous gardez mal mon coeur!

En vain, par vos conseils je me fais violence:
Je combats vainement une douce langueur:
Hélas! Vous m'engagez à faire résistance,
Et vous me laissez sans défense,
Au pouvoir de l'amour vainqueur?

Vaine fierté, faible rigueur,
Que vous avez peu de puissance
Contre l'amour et la constance!
Vaine fierté, faible rigueur,
Ah! Que vous gardez mal mon coeur!

Je vois Alphée, ô dieux! Où sera mon asile!
Mon coeur est déjà charmé,
Et ma fuite est inutile;
Hélas! Qu'il est difficile
De fuir un amant aimé!

Il approche, je tremble. Ah faut-il qu'il jouisse
Du trouble honteux où je suis?
Pardonne, amour, si je le fuis,
J'en ressens un cruel supplice;
Mais n'importe, je veux l'éviter si je puis.
Vain pride, weak resolve,
You have so little power
Against love and constancy!
Vain pride, weak resolve,
Ah! How badly you guard my heart!

In vain, through your counsel I do myself violence:
I fight in vain against a sweet languor:
Alas! You are urging me to resist,
And you leave me defenseless,
To the power of conquering love?

Vain pride, weak resolve,
You have so little power
Against love and constancy!
Vain pride, weak resolve,
Ah! How badly you guard my heart!

I see Alphaeus, oh gods! Where can be my refuge?
My heart is already charmed,
And my flight is useless;
Alas! How difficult it is
To flee from a beloved lover!

He’s coming closer, I tremble. Ah, must he soon exult
in the shameful turmoil in which I find myself?
Forgive me, love, if I flee from him,
if I feel a cruel torment;
But no matter, I must evade him if I can.

Opera after 1800

Richard Strauss: Der Rosenkavalier. Libretto by Hugo von Hofmannsthal and Count Harry Kessler; first performance 1911. Soloists with the Vienna State Opera Chorus and the Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Sir Georg Solti; recording first released 1969.

Cover of Der Rosenkavalier, London 417 493-2. Image source: Discogs.com

Der Rosenkavalier is that most unusual and fortunate of operas: it has multiple excellent audio and video recordings. These include the very first audio recording, in monophonic sound on 13 78-rpm discs, originally issued in 1933 and still available in other formats. Der Rosenkavalier has so many wonderful recordings because it has attracted many of the greatest singers and conductors (not to mention directors and designers). This version, released in 1969, is in lush stereo, and is a very welcome discovery.

In her early 40s at the time of recording, Regine Crespin has a full, plush sound as the Marschallin. Helen Donath is another in a long line of silvery-voiced Sophies, while as Octavian Yvonne Minton has a rich-timbred mezzo-soprano with a prominent but not off-putting vibrato. Although Solti has a reputation as a rather driving, urgent conductor, at 200 minutes his recording is longer than my three other favorite versions, the studio recording by Herbert von Karajan (192 minutes) and the two video productions conducted by Carlos Klieber in Munich (186 minutes) and Vienna (193 minutes).

I've written extensively about Der Rosenkavalier before, so much so that posts on the opera have their own category on E&I. So I won't belabor the work's richness or excellence. Instead, I'll just offer an excerpt of the Presentation of the Rose scene from Act II. The 17-year-old Count Octavian is carrying on a fevered affair with the older, married Marschallin. But then, acting at her request on behalf of the boorish and middle-aged Baron Ochs von Lerchenau, he presents a silver rose symbolizing the Baron's love to his new betrothed, the 16-year-old Sophie Faninal. The Baron and Sophie have never met, and there's no love involved; the deal has been arranged between the Baron and Sophie's father for their mutual advantage. But when Octavian presents the rose to Sophie, their eyes meet. . .

https://youtu.be/hP9GTEoaTGg

OCTAVIAN
Mir ist die Ehre widerfahren,
daß ich der hoch- und wohlgeborenen
Jungfer Braut,
in meines Herrn Vetters Namen,
dessen zu Lerchenau Namen,
die Rose seiner Liebe überreichen darf.
OCTAVIAN
To me has fallen the honour
of presenting to the high- and well-born
young bride,
in the name of my cousin
of Lerchenau,
the Rose of his love.
SOPHIE (nimmt die Rose)
Ich bin Euer Liebden sehr verbunden.—
Ich bin Euer Liebden
in aller Ewigkeit verbunden.—
(indem sie an der Rose riecht)
Hat einen starken Geruch. Wie Rosen,
wie lebendige.
SOPHIE (taking the Rose)
To your Lordship I am most obliged.—
To your Lordship
I am eternally obliged.—
(smelling the Rose)
It has a strong scent of roses,
real ones.
OCTAVIAN
Ja, ist ein Tropfen persischen Rosenöls
darein getan.
OCTAVIAN
Yes, a drop of Persian attar of roses
has been placed inside.
SOPHIE
Wie himmlische, nicht irdische,
wie Rosen vom hochheiligen Paradies.
Ist Ihm nicht auch?
(Octavian neigt sich über die Rose,
die sie ihm hinhält;
dann richtet er sich auf
und sieht auf ihren Mund.)

Ist wie ein Gruß vom Himmel.
Ist bereits zu stark,
als daß man’s ertragen kann.
Zieht einen nach,
als lägen Stricke um das Herz.
SOPHIE
Like roses of heaven, not of earth—
like roses of holy paradise.
Don’t you think so?
(Octavian bends over the Rose,
which she holds out to him;
then he straightens
and gazes at her mouth.)

It’s like a greeting from Heaven.
’Tis already
too strong to bear.
It draws one as though
there were reins around one’s heart.
Wo war ich schon einmal
und war so selig?

OCTAVIAN
Wo war ich schon einmal
und war so selig?

SOPHIE
Dahin muß ich zurück!
und müßt’ ich völlig
sterben auf dem Weg!
Allein, ich sterb’ ja nicht.
Das ist ja weit.
Ist Zeit und Ewigkeit
in einem sel’gen Augenblick,
den will ich nie vergessen
bis an meinen Tod.

OCTAVIAN
Ich war ein Bub’,
da hab’ ich die noch nicht gekannt.
Wer bin denn ich?
Wie komm’ denn ich zu ihr?
Wie kommt denn sie zu mir?
Wär’ ich kein Mann,
die Sinne möchten mirvergeh’n.
Das ist ein seliger Augenblick,
den will ich nie vergessen
bis an meinen Tod.
Where and when
have I been so happy?

OCTAVIAN
Where and when
have I been so happy?

SOPHIE
I must return there,
yes, even if I should die
on the way.
But I shall not die.
That is far away.
There’s Time and Eternity
in this moment of bliss—
and I’ll not forget it
until I die.

OCTAVIAN
I was a boy
and did not know her yet.
Who am I then?
How is it I come to her?
How is it she comes to me?
Were I not a man,
I should lose my senses.
This is a moment of bliss—
and I’ll not forget it
until I die.

Giacomo Puccini: Turandot. Libretto by Giuseppe Adami and Renato Simoni after the play by Friedrich Schiller; first performance 1926. Soloists with the John Alldis Choir and the London Philharmonic Orchestra, conducted by Zubin Mehta; recording first released 1972.

Cover of Turandot by Puccini

Cover of Turandot, Decca 4787815. Image source: Presto Music

Turandot is not my favorite Puccini opera (that would be La Bohème), but not because of its blatant Orientalism. Turandot is a Chinese princess whose great beauty and powerful kingdom attract princes from faraway lands seeking her hand in marriage. But she will only accept as a husband the prince who solves three riddles; those who fail are dragged away and beheaded. We learn that Turandot has vowed never to submit to a man. A distant ancestor was brutally raped and murdered when her realm was conquered by the King of Tartary; as revenge, Turandot is visiting death on any man with the temerity to aspire to marry her and rule her aged father's kingdom ("In questa reggia" (In this palace)).

But it's not the stereotype of the Ice Princess of the Cruel East that I object to, because the story is so obviously a fable. (I offer a spoiler alert for what follows.) No: I am disturbed by the needless death of the servant Liù (Monserrat Caballé), who sacrifices herself to save the name of Prince Calaf (Luciano Pavarotti) from being wrested from her by torture—as I am similarly disturbed by all the self-sacrificial Wagner heroines who die so that the hero can live (aren't heroes supposed to sacrifice themselves to save women in distress?). It curdles the ending of the opera for me, which is problematic enough: Calaf kisses Turandot against her will, a kiss that abruptly transforms her fear and hatred to love.

—End of spoilers—

So why is this opera, with its unreal characters, brutal story and problematic ending, on my list of favorites for this year? Simply because it features four of the greatest opera singers of the modern recording era, all captured at the peak of their vocal splendor and in spectacular sound.

After seeing Turandot on video and live, I had long thought that music for the character of Turandot is as difficult and unyielding as her personality—until hearing Joan Sutherland on this recording. Her voice reveals the beauty, as well as the drama, of Puccini's last music. (He died before finishing the opera; this recording uses the standard completion by Franco Alfano.) Perhaps wisely, Sutherland never essayed this voice-wrecking role onstage, but in the studio she shows herself to be a close-to-ideal Turandot.

The most famous aria in Turandot is Calaf's "Nessun dorma" (No one shall sleep; ends at 2:50). But although Pavarotti holds the climactic "Vincerò!" for a mind-boggling length of time, below I offer Liù's "Signore, ascolta," performed beautifully by Caballé and conducted with subtlety by Mehta. Liù has accompanied the defeated King of Tartary, Timur (Nicholai Ghiaurov), Calaf's father, to Peking (is the war on Tartary more of Turandot's revenge for her ancestor?). Liù has remained loyal when all the rest of Timur's entourage have fled because Prince Calaf once showed kindness to her. Timur and Liù encounter Calaf as they are about to witness the execution of the latest suitor to fail to answer the riddles. Enraptured by Turandot's beauty, though, Calaf has impulsively decided to undergo the same trial, and Liù attempts to dissuade him:

https://youtu.be/xgb5iSx7T74

Signore, ascolta!
Ah, signore, ascolta!
Liù non regge più,
Si pezza il cuore!
Ahimè, quanto cammino
col tuo nome nell'anima
col nome tuo nell'labbra
Ma se il tuo destino,
doman, sarà deciso,
noi morrem sulla strada dell'esilio.
Ei perderà suo figlio. . .
io l'ombra d'un sorriso!
Liù non regge più!
Ah!
My lord, please listen!
Ah, my lord, please listen!
Liu can bear no more,
Her heart is breaking!
Oh, how long I’ve walked
With your name in my soul,
With your name on my lips!
But if tomorrow
You meet your fate,
We will die on the road of exile.
He will lose his son,
And I, the memory of a smile.
Liù can bear no more!
Ah!

Ah, indeed.

More spoilers follow; if you want to avoid them, skip to the next opera. Liù is not a character in the Schiller play on which Turandot is based; in the play it is Calaf's aged tutor Barak who is captured by Turandot. But it may not be just Puccini's theatrical instinct that introduced the tragedy of a young female servant into the story: Liù has a real-life counterpart.

In 1903 the 16-year-old Doria Manfredi came to work as a maidservant in the Puccini household while he was convalescing from a car accident. Puccini's wife Elvira was a demanding mistress and (not without cause; Puccini had multiple affairs) a jealous woman. Doria was devoted to Puccini, and sometime in late 1908 Elvira was seized with the idea that they were carrying on an affair. As Mosco Carner relates in his critical biography of Puccini (Second Edition, Holmes & Meier, 1974), "Elvira began a veritable war against Doria" (p. 181), dismissing her, denouncing her to her relatives, spreading rumors in the town, and screaming imprecations at her if they encountered one another in the street.

After being hounded for months despite her (and for what it's worth, Puccini's) protestations of innocence, Doria committed suicide. On 6 February 1909 Puccini wrote to his friend and former lover Sybil Beddington Seligman (younger sister of the British writer Ada Leverson), ". . .poor Doria, faced with Hell in her own home and dishonour outside, and with Elvira's insults still ringing in her ears, in a moment of desperation swallowed three tablets of sublimate [highly toxic mercuric chloride], and died after five days of atrocious agony" (p. 183). Appallingly, a post-mortem examination was held "in the presence of witnesses" to determine whether Doria died a virgin; she had.

Carner writes that "it is more than probable that Doria's character, her suffering and ultimate fate" (p. 187) are represented by Liù, a devoted servant who, after experiencing torture and facing the prospect of even crueler punishments, chooses death. But if Liù embodies Doria, that means that Liù's implacable torturer, the Ice Princess Turandot, embodies Puccini's wife.

Opera on video

Baldassare Galuppi: L'Olimpiade. Libretto by Pietro Metastasio; first performed 1747. Soloists with the Venice Baroque Orchestra conducted by Andrea Marcon; video recorded 2006.

Cover of Olimpiade DVD

Cover of L'Olimpiade, Dynamic DVD 66545, recorded at the Teatro Malibran, Venice, 2006; released 2008. Image source: Internet Archive

In 1741 the 35-year-old Italian opera composer Baldassare Galuppi was brought to London as a replacement for none other than George Frideric Handel, whose opera company had failed. During his two seasons in London, Galuppi produced 11 operas and pasticci (operas with music by multiple composers); among the greatest successess was a pasticcio of one of librettist Pietro Metastasio's most popular works, L'Olimpiade.

Perhaps inspired by the reception of L'Olimpiade in London, once back in Italy Galuppi composed his own version of the opera for Milan, which was given as the first opera in the 1747–48 Carnival season. This DVD records performances of Galuppi's L'Olimpiade in 2006 at Venice's Baroque theater, Teatro Malibran. The production is sometimes puzzling, but the singing is at a high level throughout.

As with many Baroque operas, the plot is complicated but works well onstage: Licida (Franziska Gottwald) and Argene (Roberta Invernizzi) have become betrothed, but Argene's father Alcandro (Furio Zanasi), the king of Crete, rejects Licida's suit because his parentage is unknown. Heartbroken (but still in search of a wife) Licida learns that Clistene (Mark Tucker), king of Sicyon, is offering his daughter Aristea (Ruth Rosique) in marriage to the winner of the Olympic Games. To gain the bride, Licida asks Megacle (Romina Basso), a renowned athlete, to compete in his stead and under his name.

He doesn't realize that Megacle himself loves Aristea, and his love is returned. But Megacle owes his life to Licida and feels that honor requires him to do as his friend asks, without enlightening him. Meanwhile, Argene has followed Licida to Sicyon disguised as a shepherdess in order to avoid her father's decree that she marry a man she doesn't love: none other than Megacle.

Since this is a Baroque opera, ultimately disguises are revealed, long-lost sons are found, and the correct couples are united. But not before each of the major characters finds themselves in a succession of situations in which they face an intense conflict, either an inner dilemma or a confrontation with another character. And each emotionally fraught situation gives rise to an aria of sorrow, anger, hope, defiance, despair, or love.

At the end of Act I, Megacle meets with Aristea as he is preparing to leave for the Games. She is overjoyed at seeing him, but to her bewilderment Megacle bids her a sorrowful farewell. The duet "Ne' giorni tuoi felici" from the video of the Teatro Malibran production, with Romina Basso as Megacle and Ruth Rosique as Aristea.

https://youtu.be/pIrTm4JVaSg?t=4217 [duet ends at 1:18:41]

Megacle:
Ne' giorni tuoi felici
Ricordati di me.

Aristea:
Perchè cosi mi dici,
Anima mia, perchè?

Megacle:
Taci, bell' idol mio.

Aristea:
Parla, mio dolce amor.

Megacle:
Ah, che parlando

Aristea:
Ah, che tacendo

À due:
Oh dio!
Tu mi traffiggi il cor.

Aristea:
(Veggio languir chi adoro,
Ne intendo il suo languir.)

Megacle:
(Di gelosia mi moro,
E non lo posso dir.)

À due:
Chi mai provò di questo
Affanno più funesto
Più barbaro dolor.
Megacle:
In your happy future days,
remember me.

Aristea:
Why are you saying this to me,
my love, why?

Megacle:
Ask me not, my beautiful one.

Aristea:
Then speak to me, my sweet love.

Megacle:
If only I could speak—

Aristea:
What chilling silence—

Together:
O God,
my heart is breaking.

Aristea:
(I see my beloved is suffering,
but I don't understand why.)

Megacle:
(I die of jealousy,
And I cannot say anything.)

Together:
Who has ever felt
more deadly anguish,
more barbaric pain.

For more please see the full-length post, "Farewell to hope": Baldassare Galuppi's L'Olimpiade.

(Dis)Honorable mention

Giuseppe Verdi: La Traviata. Libretto by Francesco Maria Piave after La Dame aux camélias (1852) by Alexandre Dumas fils; first performed 1853. Soloists with the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra and Chorus conducted by James Levine; directed and designed by Franco Zeffirelli; original film released 1982.

Cover of La Traviata, Deutsche Grammophon DVD 00440 073 4364; original film released 1982. Image source: Deutsche Grammophon

Franco Zeffirelli directed and designed what I consider to be the best La Bohème on video (the 1965 film with a young Mirella Freni as Mimi) and a well-regarded Otello (in the mid-1980s, with Plácido Domingo and Katia Ricciarelli). His stage production of La Bohème at the Metropolitan Opera debuted in 1981, and is also available with at least two different casts on video. More than 40 years and 500 performances later it remains in the Met's repertory; the most recent revival was this fall.

But mention Zeffirelli in certain company and the response will be a sneer. He is viewed as exemplifying a dead tradition: producing operas with lavish sets and costumes that portray the time and place intended by the composer and librettist. (How stultifyingly literal! How empty of ideas!)

Even his detractors would acknowledge his familiarity with the score and close attention to detail in the acting, not only of the principals but of everyone onstage. And I find that his predilection for sumptuousness and visual excess is well-matched to the world of hedonistic opulence in which the action of La Traviata takes place.

Both Teresa Stratas and Plácido Domingo give impassioned performances, but this is Stratas' film. Her singing in the supremely difficult part of Violetta is compelling, and her embodiment of the doomed courtesan as she hurtles toward her inexorable fate is heartwrenching. The pace at which the story unfolds is even swifter than usual, as about 15 minutes has been trimmed from the opera's two-hour running time.

Here is the famous Brindisi ("toast" or "drinking song") from Act I. Apart from Domingo's Alfredo and Stratas' Violetta, this sequence features Maurizio Barbacini as Alfredo's friend Gastone, Allan Monk as Alfredo's rival the Baron, and Axelle Gall as Violetta's friend and fellow courtesan Flora.

https://youtu.be/Krzj73WQ6eI [The Brindisi sequence ends around 5:15]

But an aspect of this film does disturb me, and it's not the visual style. Zeffirelli has been accused by multiple men of unwanted sexual contact. Among those who have made allegations against him are Johnathon Schaech, who appeared in Zeffirelli's 1993 film Sparrow and later played the lead singer of The Wonders in the 1996 movie That Thing You Do!, and Bruce Robinson, who played Benvolio in Zeffirelli's 1968 Romeo and Juliet. And after Zeffirelli's death in 2019 the stars of Romeo and Juliet, Leonard Whiting and Olivia Hussey, filed lawsuits claiming that they did not consent to the film's nude scene (they were 17 and 16, respectively, during the filming in 1967); the lawsuits were dismissed. In a 1968 television interview Hussey mentions that the scene was described to them during auditions, and in an interview after a 2016 screening of Romeo and Juliet at The American Cinematheque in Los Angeles, spoke admiringly of Zeffirelli. But of course there was a huge power imbalance between the relatively unknown young actors and the famous director. I find the scene touching and tender, not prurient or exploitative, but it was filmed before intimacy coordinators were brought in and would be handled differently today.

Plácido Domingo has faced allegations made in 2019 and 2023 about sexual advances towards more than 20 female colleagues that included unwanted kissing, touching, and persistent solicitation. Domingo was one of the most powerful figures in opera as one of its greatest stars, the head of a prestigious international voice competition (Operalia), and director of two major U.S. companies (Washington and Los Angeles). He issued a statement that said in part, "I am truly sorry for the hurt that I caused" and "I accept full responsibility for my actions," but has also said "I never abused anyone."

James Levine's career at the Met was ended in 2018 when allegations surfaced stretching back to the late 1960s of the sexual coercion of young male musicians and singers for whom he was in a position of authority as a teacher, mentor, and conductor.

That these three men could participate in a production of La Traviata—an opera that portrays its courtesan protagonist in a deeply sympathetic light—while at the same time allegedly engaging in the sexual exploitation of those less powerful, is a contradiction that I find impossible to resolve; thus my mixed feelings about this video.

Next time: Favorites of 2026: Live and streamed performances

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Favorites of 2026: Vocal and instrumental music recordings

It's time once again for my favorite music, movies and books first encountered (but not necessarily first issued) in 2026.

When thinking about the list of my favorite recordings from this year I was concerned that my list would be too short, but I needn't have worried. In fact, it's so long I'm dividing this post into two parts: the first will cover vocal and instrumental music, and the second full-length opera. In roughly chronological order by date of composition:

Music before 1800

Virginie Thomas: Nymphes (L'Encelade ECL 2203, released 2023) and Mademoiselle Hilaire (L'Encelade ECL 2502, released 2025)

Virginie Thomas

Virginie Thomas. Image credit: Studio Ledroit-Perrin. Image source: Les Heures Musicales de l’Abbaye de Lessay

These albums showcase Thomas' beautifully clear and pure soprano in the performance of airs written by composers such as Lully, Desmarest, Campra, Leclair, Lambert, Cavalli, and others. On Nymphes Thomas arranges airs into a mini-opera describing the progress of the Nymph of the Seine as she emerges into the human world, discovers the pleasures and pains of love, and finally retreats into "darkness and silence." On Mademoiselle Hilaire Thomas performs airs written specifically for Hilaire Dupuis, a singer in Louis XIV's court, by Dupuis' brother-in-law (Lambert), her niece's husband (Lully), and others.

"Recit de l'Aurore," from Lully and Molière's La Princesse d'Elide, is typical of the lightness and grace with which Thomas performs this exquisite music:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=46AsyU-8Xmc

Quand l'amour à vos yeux offre un choix agréable,
Jeune beauté laissez-vous enflammer;
Moquez-vous d'affecter cet orgueil indomptable
Dont on vous dit
Qu'il est beau de s'armer.
Dans l'âge où l'on est aimable
Rien n'est si beau que d'aimer.

Soupirez librement pour un amant fidèle,
Et bravez ceux qui voudraient vous blâmer;
Un cœur tendre est aimable, et le nom de cruelle
N'est pas un nom à se faire estimer.
Dans le temps où l'on est belle
Rien n'est si beau que d'aimer.
When love seems to offer you a pleasant choice,
Young beauty, allow yourself to be set alight;
Trouble not to feign that indomitable pride
That is so often said to be
Such a fine weapon in one's armoury.
When you are of an age to be loved
There can be naught finer than to love.

Sigh freely for a true lover,
And defy those who would criticise you;
A tender heart can be loved, and being called "cruel"
Is no way to gain others' esteem.
For as long as you have beauty
There can be naught finer than to love.

For more, please see my full-length review of Nymphes and Mademoiselle Hilaire.

Vivaldi for diverse instruments. Philharmonia Baroque Orchestra conducted by Nicholas McGegan.

Cover of Vivaldi for diverse instruments, Reference Recordings RR-77CD, released 1997. Image source: Presto Music

Nicholas McGegan served as music director of Philharmonia Baroque Orchestra for 35 years, assuming the position of music director laureate at the end of the 2019-20 season. He brought the group into international prominence and set up a program of regular recording, which now continues on PBO's own label.

This exuberant album of Vivaldi concertos from 1997 showcases the group's virtuosity, featuring soloists from the ensemble: violinists Elizabeth Blumenstock, Katherine Kyme and Lisa Weiss, oboists Marc Schachman and Gonzalo X. Ruiz, bassoonist Heather Carruthers, and horn players R.J. Kelley and Paul Avril. Discovering it was a lovely way for us to re-experience the ensemble that played a key role in developing our love of Baroque music (see the post Attunement for our conversion experience).

The first movement, "Allegro," from the Concerto in F for violin (Blumenstock), 2 horns, 2 oboes and bassoon:

https://youtu.be/_Rc26tzVi5U

Johann Adolf Hasse: Salve Regina. Barbara Bonney and Bernarda Fink, soloists, with Musica Antiqua Köln conducted by Reinhard Goebel.

Cover of Salve Regina by Hasse

Cover of Salve Regina, Arkiv Produktion 453 435-2, released 1997. Image source: Presto Music

Johann Adolf Hasse, although hugely popular and influential in his own time, has been underperformed and underrecorded in ours, at least in comparison to his older contemporaries Handel and Vivaldi. The Presto Music catalog includes nearly 7,000 recordings of Handel works, 5,000 by Vivaldi, but just over 300 by Hasse. (Nonetheless, two Hasse works were among my Favorites of 2025: Recordings.)

Hasse wrote three settings of the Salve Regina. Two of them, the setting in A major for contralto and the setting in E flat major for soprano and contralto, are included in this recording. Bernarda Fink is not a contralto, but rather a mezzo-soprano. It shows occasionally in her lowest notes, which are not as full or rich-sounding as those of a true contralto. But she is one of my favorite singers, as is soprano Barbara Bonney (who appears again below). The two are lovely both separately and in duet, as in the final movement of the Salve Regina in E flat major:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f1X8l1dSw6g

Et Iesum, benedictum fructum ventris tui,
nobis, post hoc exsilium ostende.
O clemens: O pia: O dulcis
Virgo Maria.
And after this our exile, show unto us
Jesus, the blessed fruit of thy womb,
O merciful, O loving, O sweet
Virgin Mary.

Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach: Cello Concertos. Anner Bylsma, violoncello, with Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment conducted by Gustav Leonhardt.

Cover of Cello Concertos and Symphonies by CPE Bach

Cover of C.P.E. Bach, Symphonies [&] Cello Concertos. Erato Veritas 5617942, recorded 1988. Image source: Presto Music

In our day, C.P.E. Bach is seen as a transitional figure between the High Baroque style exemplified by his father Johann Sebastian Bach and the later Classical style. But during C.P.E. Bach's lifetime his fame far eclipsed that of his father. Known as "The Berlin Bach" to distinguish him from his equally famous half-brother Johann Christian ("The London Bach"), he was court composer to Frederick the Great of Prussia, and later succeeded Telemann as director of sacred music in Hamburg. Over a career lasting six decades he composed more than 1000 works. He was also a renowned teacher; his Essay on the True Art of Playing Keyboard Instruments (1753) went through multiple editions by the end of the century and was studied by Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven.

The great Dutch period-instrument cellist Anner Bylsma passed away in 2019, but I am grateful that he recorded extensively; it means that there are still recordings of his for me to discover. The second movement "Largo con sordini, mesto" (broadly with mutes, mournfully) from Cello Concerto No. 3 in A major, composed in 1753:

https://youtu.be/tqdUO_ooGpg

Music after 1800

Franz Schubert: Lieder. Barbara Bonney, soprano, with Geoffrey Parsons, piano, and Sharon Kam, clarinet on "Der Hirt auf dem Felsen."

Cover of Schubert: Lieder, Teldec/Warner 2564 69719-3, recorded 1994. Image source: Presto Music

To my surprise, given my previous resistance to art song as a form, albums of Schubert lieder sung by the Dutch soprano Elly Ameling have featured on my favorite recordings list for 2024 and 2025. More surprising is that even though Ameling was in the running again, Barbara Bonney is this year's Schubert favorite.

Bonney began her career as a lyric soprano in opera, and for a decade or so was the reigning Sophie in Richard Strauss' Der Rosenkavalier. Her performances in this role at the Royal Opera House Covent Garden in 1985 conducted by Georg Solti, and Vienna Staatsoper in 1994 conducted by Carlos Kleiber, are both on video; from the latter you can see her final love duet with Anne Sofie von Otter's Octavian in the post Anne Sofie von Otter: Swan Song.

But Bonney has also devoted herself to lieder throughout her career. And in mid-career, for two seasons between 1999 and 2001 she performed only in recitals. Her performances of lieder by Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel have been featured before on E&I; see the posts on Sounds and Sweet Airs: The Forgotten Women of Classical Music and Shakespeare's sisters: Fanny Mendelssohn Hensel and Maria Anna Mozart. So perhaps I should have anticipated the appeal of her selection of Schubert lieder.

A word about why Elly Ameling is not on this list. This year I came across her entry in accompanist Graham Johnson's Hyperion Schubert Edition Complete Songs series (Vol 7: Schubert in 1815, Vol. 1)), and confidently expected it to be on this list. I think Ameling's voice is almost perfectly suited to this repertoire, and Graham Johnson's liner notes give a detailed analysis of each song. But as the very title of the Hyperion disc suggests, it is aimed at Schubert completists. In 1815, the 18-year-old Schubert wrote 140 songs, or an average of almost a dozen each month, a pace that would have left the Elvis Costello of 1979–80 in the dust. Not all of the teenaged Schubert's songs are masterpieces, either musically or poetically. Ameling's disc opens with the obscure 11-minute opus "Minona," the rewards of which (despite Johnson's advocacy) don't justify its running time.

I appreciate Johnson's archival impulse, and would not want to be without Ameling's performance of songs such as "Meeres Still," setting a poem by Goethe. But I think I'll be listening to the Bonney recording significantly more often. It is filled with songs of a consistently high level, Bonney's voice is fresh and pure, and her accompanist Geoffrey Parsons subtle and supportive.

Bonney's Schubert selection opens with the simple and lovely "Ellens Gesang III: Hymne an die Jungfrau 'Ave Maria'," one of his best-known works. The poem is one of seven passages from Sir Walter Scott's The Lady of the Lake translated by Adam Storck into German and set by Schubert in 1825. In this sequence from Canto Third, the heroine Ellen Douglas and her exiled (but loyal) father have fled their dwelling at the approach of the King's forces, and sheltered in the Goblin's Cave. There Ellen offers up a prayer for safety to the Virgin Mary; the piano suggests the lone harp that accompanies her:

https://youtu.be/tDQj7j-xogM

Ave Maria! Jungfrau mild,
Erhöre einer Jungfrau Flehen,
Aus diesem Felsen starr und wild
Soll mein Gebet zu dir hinwehen.
Wir schlafen sicher bis zum Morgen,
Ob Menschen noch so grausam sind.
O Jungfrau, sieh der Jungfrau Sorgen,
O Mutter, hör ein bittend Kind!
Ave Maria!

Ave Maria! Unbefleckt!
Wenn wir auf diesen Fels hinsinken
Zum Schlaf, und uns dein Schutz bedeckt
Wird weich der harte Fels uns dünken.
Du lächelst, Rosendüfte wehen
In dieser dumpfen Felsenkluft,
O Mutter, höre Kindes Flehen,
O Jungfrau, eine Jungfrau ruft!
Ave Maria!

Ave Maria! Reine Magd!
Der Erde und der Luft Dämonen,
Von deines Auges Huld verjagt,
Sie können hier nicht bei uns wohnen.
Wir woll’n uns still dem Schicksal beugen,
Da uns dein heil’ger Trost anweht;
Der Jungfrau wolle hold dich neigen,
Dem Kind, das für den Vater fleht.
Ave Maria!
Ave Maria! maiden mild!
Listen to a maiden's prayer!
Thou canst hear though from the wild;
Thou canst save amid despair.
Safe may we sleep beneath thy care,
Though banish'd, outcast and reviled—
Maiden! hear a maiden's prayer;
Mother, hear a suppliant child!
Ave Maria!

Ave Maria! undefiled!
The flinty couch we now must share
Shall seem with down of eider piled,
If thy protection hover there.
The murky cavern's heavy air
Shall breathe of balm if thou hast smiled;
Then, Maiden! hear a maiden's prayer,
Mother, list a suppliant child!
Ave Maria!

Ave Maria! stainless styled.
Foul demons of the earth and air,
From this their wonted haunt exiled,
Shall flee before thy presence fair.
We bow us to our lot of care,
Beneath thy guidance reconciled;
Hear for a maid a maiden's prayer,
And for a father hear a child!
Ave Maria!

Additional favorites 

Ella Fitzgerald: Like Someone in Love, with Stan Getz (tenor sax) and Ted Nash (alto sax); orchestra arranged and conducted by Frank DeVol.

Cover of Like Someone in Love by Ella Fitzgerald

Cover of Like Someone in Love, Verve 314 511 524-2, released 1957. Photo credit: Phil Stern. Image source: Goatless

Like Someone in Love is Ella Fitzgerald's In the Wee Small Hours, an album of torch songs that creates a hushed mood. The songs express anticipation and yearning; the joys of dawning love and the sorrow of inevitable loss. Ella's inimitable voice had gained warmth but lost little of its purity as she entered her 40s. Cushioned by DeVol's lush string arrangements and accompanied on four of the tracks by Stan Getz's understated soloing, Ella's singing is seductive, caressing, and sometimes mournful. A treasurable album of songs mostly new to me from the period when she was at her considerable peak.

"Then I'll Be Tired of You," with music by Arthur Schwartz and lyrics by Yip Harburg:

https://youtu.be/BdaXz-Du7XU

I'll be tired of you
When stars are tired of gleaming,
When I am tired of dreaming,
Then I'll be tired of you.

This I know is true,
When winds are tired of blowing,
When grass is tired of growing,
Then I'll be tired of you.

Beyond the years,
'Til day is night,
'Til wrong is right,
'Til birds refuse to sing,

Beyond the years,
The echo of my only love
Will still be whispering,
Whispering. . .

And if my throbbing heart
Should ever start repeating
That it is tired of beating,
Then I'll be tired of you.

For more, please see my full-length review of Like Someone in Love.

Marianne Faithfull: "A Perfect Stranger": The Island Anthology.

Cover of A Perfect Stranger by Marianne Faithfull

Cover of "A Perfect Stranger": The Island Anthology, Island 314 524 579-2, released 1998. Image source: Amazon.fr

When I first heard Marianne Faithfull's Broken English in the late 1970s, I was taken aback. I knew of her from her mid-60s folk-pop version of "As Tears Go By." (If you follow the link, the song ends at 3:05, and is followed by a brief interview with the Hullabaloo host Brian Epstein.) Faithfull's version is the original, as I didn't learn until recently; although written by Mick Jagger and Keith Richards (in fact, the first song they wrote together), the Stones' version wasn't released until a year after she'd made it a hit. Faithfull's voice during this period has been described as "ethereal" and "fragile," but I hear an untrained but appealing mezzo-soprano.

She spent a few eventful years in the late 1960s as Jagger's girlfriend, during which she co-wrote and recorded "Sister Morphine," only to see the songwriting credits omit her, and the single on which it was the B-side withdrawn by her record company. (She had to file a lawsuit to get credit.) She also appeared as Ophelia in director Tony Richardson's 1969 film version of Hamlet. Then Faithfull pretty much disappeared from public view.

When she re-emerged after a decade largely lost to alcohol and heroin, her voice had deepened and was ragged and raw. As Ann Powers writes in the liner notes of "A Perfect Stranger," Faithfull's ravaged voice "communicated a personal history that required no specifics. . .[taking] listeners into a darkness that was hers but also anyone's who had been silenced." She sounded like she'd been through an entire lifetime of hard experience; she was only 32.

The songs on Broken English were grief-stricken and world-weary, with a seething anger beneath the surface that could erupt spectacularly—as on "Why'd ya do it," her furious break-up song directed at an unfaithful lover. I learned when writing this post that the words are by the poet Heathcote Williams. Faithfull grabs this poem of male griping about the anger of the woman he's betrayed and turns its on its head; it becomes her enraged dismissal of him.

"A Perfect Stranger" is a selection of Faithfull's work from 1979 to 1995. There are generous inclusions from Broken English and the cabaret-style Strange Weather (1987), and songs culled from less-consistent records, as well as soundtracks, tribute albums, unreleased sessions and live performances. There are some omissions—where is the harshly self-reflective "She's Got A Problem," from A Child's Adventure (1983)?—but her work proves, in the words of a Guardian headline, that she was an artist, not just a muse. After 1995 she would go on to record for another two and a half decades, dying at age 78 in January 2025.

From Broken English, Faithfull's searing cover of John Lennon's "Working Class Hero":

https://youtu.be/8yw89f9kNko

As soon as you're born they make you feel small
By giving you no time instead of it all
Till the pain is so big you feel nothing at all
A working class hero is something to be

They hurt you at home and they hit you at school
They hate you if you're clever and they despise a fool
Till you're so fucking crazy you can't follow their rules
A working class hero is something to be

When they've tortured and scared you for twenty-odd years
And then they expect you to pick a career
But you really can't function, you're so full of fear
A working class hero is something to be

Keep you doped with religion and sex and TV
And you think you're so clever and classless and free
But you're still fucking peasants as far as I can see
A working class hero is something to be

There's room at the top, they are telling you still
But first you must learn how to smile as you kill
If you want to live like the folks on the hill
A working class hero is something to be

Biggest disappointment

Uri Caine / Gustav Mahler: Dark Flame. Uri Caine Ensemble.

Cover of Dark Flame, Music Edition | Winter & Winter 910 095, released 2003. Image source: jpc.de

In my household a disc that is never far from our CD player is Wagner e Venezia, an album of Wagner "adaptations" performed by the pianist Uri Caine and his ensemble, and recorded live in Venice. Here is the opening track, "Mild und Liese" from Tristan und Isolde,  otherwise known as the Liebestod (Love-Death):

https://youtu.be/FZYb3i37ve0?t=66

Most of the Wagner arrangements are inventive but recognizable echoes of their orchestral counterparts, but for "Ride of the Valkyries" Caine cleverly mashes up Die Walküre and Paul Dukas' The Sorcerer's Apprentice, to witty effect. Then there's the moment as the ensemble is reaching the final measures of the overture to Die Meistersinger von Nurnberg and the stately bells of the Campanile San Marco ring out in perfect time with the music.

Wagner e Venezia is so good that when I came across Caine's reimaginings of Mahler lieder, Dark Flame, I didn't hesitate. (OK, it only cost 50 cents, but these days I have no place to put any more CDs, so I choose carefully.) As soon as I put it in my player, though, anticipation turned to dismay. I found it unlistenable. Spoken word is sprinkled liberally throughout the album, and Mahler's haunting melodies are so transformed as to be unrecognizable. A crashing disappointment.

My admiration for Wagner e Venezia remains unstinting, but on the basis of Dark Flame I don't think I'm going to be doing any further exploration of Uri Caine's discography right away. You may feel differently, of course. Should you be curious you can listen on YouTube or other streaming services.

Next time: Favorites of 2026: Opera recordings

Saturday, October 17, 2026

The Other Bennet Sister: the Janice Hadlow novel

Cover of The Other Bennet Sister by Janice Hadlow

Cover of the U.S. edition of The Other Bennet Sister by Janice Hadlow, Holt Paperbacks, 2021. Image source: Bookshop.org

In Pride and Prejudice, Mary Bennet is the overlooked and scorned Bennet sister. Using the first edition as digitized by Project Gutenberg, I did a word count: Elizabeth is mentioned 768 times, including forms of her name such as Lizzy (used by family members), Eliza (used by Charlotte Lucas), and Miss Bennet (used by social acquaintances when Jane is not present); Jane is mentioned 331 times (including as Miss Bennet); Lydia, 171; Kitty (also as Catherine), 81; and Mary, a mere 37. While I make no claims for the absolute accuracy of these numbers, their relative magnitude is notable: Elizabeth is mentioned 20 times more often than Mary.

On those rare occasions when Mary is referenced, the narrator's descriptions are not kind; words associated with her include "moraliz[ing]," "plain," "pedantic," "conceited," and "affected." She is the object of several cutting narratorial remarks. At her very first appearance, in fact, we learn that "Mary wished to say something very sensible, but knew not how" (Vol. I, Ch. I). Later, we are told that she "piqued herself on the solidity of her reflections" (Vol. I, Ch. V); that her "vanity" (rather than her love for music) makes her "always impatient for display" although she "had neither genius or taste" (Vol. I, Ch. VI); and that "an opportunity of exhibiting was delightful to her" although her musical performances are greeted with "derision" by her younger sisters—hardly paragons of taste, but (like many teenagers before and since) unsympathetic connoisseurs of the ridiculous (Vol. I, Ch. XVIII).

When Jane and Elizabeth return home from Netherfield after Jane's illness, "They found Mary, as usual, deep in the study of thorough bass and human nature; and had some new extracts to admire, and some new observations of thread-bare morality to listen to" (Vol. I, Ch. XII). Later we hear an example of that threadbare morality when the Bennets learn that Lydia has eloped with Wickham, but there are no signs that a marriage has taken place. At the dinner table Mary says to Elizabeth,

"Unhappy as the event must be for Lydia, we may draw from it this useful lesson; that loss of virtue in a female is irretrievable—that one false step involves her in endless ruin—that her reputation is no less brittle than it is beautiful,—and that she cannot be too much guarded in her behaviour towards the undeserving of the other sex."

Elizabeth lifted up her eyes in amazement, but was too much oppressed to make any reply. Mary, however, continued to console herself with such kind of moral extractions from the evil before them. (Vol. III, Ch. V)

Mary's self-consolation is misplaced. Elizabeth understands that Lydia's "endless ruin" will encompass all of her sisters, who, due to the ineradicable stain of their sister's disgrace, will be viewed as pariahs by eligible men.

Janice Hadlow's brilliant conceit in The Other Bennet Sister (Henry Holt, 2020) is to view the action of Pride and Prejudice from the point of view of the neglected, isolated, and awkward Mary. Hadlow's novel became the basis of the excellent 2026 BBC television series. Like the series, Hadlow's novel far exceeded my expectations: I thought it was well-structured, well-written and engaging, and would recommend it to readers open to imagining the lives of Austen's characters outside of the action of her novels. [1]

Janice Hadlow

Janice Hadlow in 2013, when she was controller in charge of programming for BBC 2. Image source: BBC Radio 4

Inevitably, there are small and large differences between the novel and series. Some changes made for the series have the evident intention of heightening the drama which, in a visual medium, must be shown. Novels, of course, can give us greater access to the characters' thoughts and feelings, and it is in the relation of Mary's interior world that Hadlow's novel is most vividly imagined.

Among the more significant differences: in the novel Mary does not go to the Gardiners' house as governess to their children as she does in the series, and so there are no painful scenes of the "governess-trade" (as Jane Fairfax calls it in Austen's Emma). Tom Hayward's character in the novel is less awkward and more at ease in company, but still slow to express his feelings. The explanation of his reticence in the novel is not his understanding with another woman, as it is in the series, but rather his own feelings of constraint due to his precarious position as a barrister just starting his career.

The series aligns Tom strongly with Sense and Sensibility's Edward Ferrars, while the novel suggests parallels with another Austen hero, Captain Frederick Wentworth of Persuasion. Like Wentworth when he first meets Anne Elliot, Tom has "no hopes of attaining affluence, but in the chances of a most uncertain profession" (Persuasion, Ch. IV). It is only after the successful resolution of his first important case that Tom is in a financial and reputational position that would enable him to approach Mary as a suitor rather than a friend.

When Tom accompanies the Gardiners and Mary on their visit to the Lakes, he and Mary are drawn closer together, and she begins to anticipate, and hope, that he may make a declaration. But when they are joined by a party consisting of Tom's free-thinking friend William Ryder, together with Mary's nemesis Caroline Bingley, Caroline's snooty sister Mrs. Hurst and her sot of a husband, Tom withdraws emotionally and behaves towards Mary with greater coolness and reserve.

She is at a loss to understand why he has suddenly become more remote, but is determined to have the chance to find out by joining him and the others on a hike up the high peak of Scafell. Despite Mrs. Gardiner's repeated hints that she and Mary might be more comfortable remaining at the inn, having tea and reading books, "Mary was not to be persuaded" (p. 370). And it is on the expedition up Scafell that a bitter remark of Tom's about Ryder brings enlightenment to Mary about the reasons for Tom's change of manner:

As Mary stood watching him walk away, it burst upon her quite suddenly that Mr. Hayward was jealous—jealous of his friend. It was such an extraordinary idea that it took a moment for her to absorb it. At first it seemed preposterous, presumptuous even—who was she, after all, to imagine two men could feel strongly enough about her to arouse such a sensation?. . .But she could think of no other way to account for Mr. Hayward's behaviour over the past few days. His discomfort had been very marked when he had seen her in Mr. Ryder's company. His silent withdrawal when he met them walking from the inn—his obvious ill humour just now, so unlike his usual open, frank disposition—what else could it imply but displeasure with what he regarded as his friend's overtures to her? (p. 374)

Mary's thoughts, expressed in free indirect style, echo those of Persuasion's Anne Elliot when she attends a concert at the Bath Assembly Rooms in a family party that includes her cousin, William Elliot. Mr. Elliot pays her marked attentions, which are observed by an increasingly unhappy Captain Wentworth. At the first opportunity Wentworth abruptly informs Anne that he is leaving the concert.

"Is not this song worth staying for?" said Anne, suddenly struck by an idea which made her yet more anxious to be encouraging.

"No!" he replied impressively, "there is nothing worth my staying for;" and he was gone directly.

Jealousy of Mr Elliot! It was the only intelligible motive. Captain Wentworth jealous of her affection! Could she have believed it a week ago; three hours ago! For a moment the gratification was exquisite. But, alas! there were very different thoughts to succeed. How was such jealousy to be quieted? How was the truth to reach him? How, in all the peculiar disadvantages of their respective situations, would he ever learn of her real sentiments? It was misery to think of Mr Elliot’s attentions. Their evil was incalculable. (Ch. XX)

The Other Bennet Sister is filled with allusions to Austen's novels, and to the 1995 BBC series of Pride and Prejudice adapted by Andrew Davies. (Hadlow's representation of the character of Mrs. Bennet in particular seems to draw significantly on the indelible performance of Alison Steadman in the 1995 series.) To my occasional annoyance, some famous passages in Pride and Prejudice are given weaker paraphrases in The Other Bennet Sister, and when they are recognizably quoted they are often placed in the mouths of different characters or given different meanings or contexts.

One example must serve for many. The opening sentence of Pride and Prejudice is one of the most famous in all English literature: "It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single man in possession of a good fortune must be in want of a wife." In the 1995 BBC series Andrew Davies gives this line (shorn of the first phrase) to Elizabeth, who speaks it archly to her sisters as their mother informs Mr. Bennet of the arrival in their neighborhood of a rich unmarried man, Mr. Bingley. In The Other Bennet Sister, that first phrase missing from the 1995 series finds a place in a conversation between two other characters, and is given a different context: here it is asserted not that everyone knows that rich single men must be looking for marriage partners, but that women should not aspire to matches above their station:

"Confine yourself to your proper sphere, Miss Bennet. Do not trespass where you cannot hope to succeed. . .Presumption of that kind leads only to disappointment and humiliation where matters of the heart are concerned."

Mary had promised herself she would not allow Caroline Bingley to provoke her, that she would not sink to exchanging insults—but she could contain herself no longer. . .

"You seem to know a great deal about rejection. Is this a lesson you have learnt from extensive study? Or do you perhaps owe it to experience of a more personal nature?"

. . ."I speak only from what I have observed. It is a truth universally acknowledged, I believe." (p. 306) [2]

But these minor incongruencies with Austen's novel are, in the end, not too bothersome a flaw, and may be the author's way of signalling the reader not to expect any attempt at exact duplication of Austen's characters. What I said of the series—that it is "much more than a pastiche of characters and scenes from Austen"—is true also of the book. We follow Mary as she grows and takes chances she would not have dared before. And we see her learn the bitter lesson that it's not only true that, as her reading of Aristotle tells her, we can make our own happiness, but we can also, through misunderstanding and false pride, make our own misery. The Other Bennet Sister stands on its own as a nuanced and imaginative expansion of Austen's characters and their world.

For my post on the 2026 BBC series, please see The Other Bennet Sister.


  1. As I mention in my post on the BBC series (link immediately above), Jane Austen herself was not averse to imagining the continuing lives of her characters after the end of the novels—including Mary.
  2. Of course, Mary's reference to Caroline's "extensive study" of romantic disappointment is a faint echo of a conversation among Darcy, Caroline Bingley and Elizabeth in Pride and Prejudice where Darcy asserts that in addition to dancing, drawing, music, and a smattering of French and Italian, a truly accomplished woman "must yet add something more substantial in the improvement of her mind by extensive reading” (Ch. VIII).

Sunday, October 4, 2026

Newspaper noir: While the City Sleeps

Lobby card for While the City Sleeps, directed by Fritz Lang, 1956

Lobby card for When the City Sleeps (1956), directed by Fritz Lang. Image source: FilmAffinity US

In film noir, we're faced with a world of corruption and evil which leaves no character untouched. The morally compromised protagonist may be an ex-con (Jeff Bailey in Out of the Past (1947)), sleep with his partner's wife (Sam Spade in The Maltese Falcon (1941)), or stick his neck out for none of the desperate refugees who crowd into his bar (Rick Blaine in Casablanca (1943)). But he moves through the world abiding by his own hard-won code, although it may lead him into danger or even death. A late Fritz Lang film, While the City Sleeps (1956), takes the morally compromised protagonist to new depths.

A killer is stalking women in New York City. A librarian and a schoolteacher—symbols of vulnerable single womanhood—have been found brutally murdered; at the scene of the first crime, "Ask Mother" has been written on the wall with the victim's lipstick. The New York Sentinel newspaper whips up a frenzy (and boosts circulation) by leading almost every edition with screaming headlines about the Lipstick Killer. [1]

Lipstick Killer Still At Large headline

The Sentinel whips up a frenzy.

At this moment of crisis Walter Kyne (Vincent Price), the idle and pleasure-loving son of the founder of the Sentinel, takes over the flagship paper his father built over decades and ran with an unerring news sense even as he laying dying in his sickbed. Kyne has no intention of being a hands-on owner; he just wants to enjoy the vast wealth his inherited media empire generates. But he has no idea which of several candidates to choose to run the place in his absence.

So Kyne creates a new position, Executive Director (or as he describes it, "someone to do the actual work"). To fill it he sets up a cutthroat competition to solve the Lipstick Killer case, which pits the smarmy head of the wire service Mark Loving (George Sanders), the hard-nosed managing editor of the newspaper Jon Griffith (Thomas Mitchell), and the playboy photo service chief Harry Kritzer (James Craig) against one another. The paper's star reporter and the anchor of its nightly television news show, Ed Mobley (Dana Andrews), tries to keep himself above the fray, but that proves to be impossible.

The newsroom is an incestuous stew. Mobley is dating Loving's virginal secretary Nancy Liggett (Sally Forrest), whom Loving also—Lovingly?—drapes his arm around when she's in his office.

Nancy attempts to peel Loving's hand off her shoulder while taking dictation

Nancy attempts to peel Loving's hand off her shoulder while taking dictation.

Meanwhile, Loving has a dissatisfied mistress, columnist Mildred Donner (Ida Lupino), whom he sends to seduce Mobley to get information. She doesn't seem too unhappy about the assignment.

Mildred gives Mobley the eye

Mildred gives Mobley the eye over a drink or four.

And Kritzer is sleeping with Kyne's brassy wife Dorothy (Rhonda Fleming), who tries to plant suggestions in her husband's ear that favor her lover. In a coincidence that will have importance in the plot, their love nest is directly across the hall from Nancy's apartment.

Incidentally, any resemblance between Ed Mobley and Edward Murrow is probably intentional. The film is adapted by veteran screenwriter Casey Robinson from Charles Einstein's 1953 novel The Bloody Spur (whose title is taken from Shakespeare's Julius Caesar: "But hollow men, like horses hot at hand,/Make gallant show and promise of their mettle./But when they should endure the bloody spur,/They fall their crests and, like deceitful jades,/Sink in the trial"). At the time Einstein's novel was published, Murrow's television career was well underway; by the time the film was in production his two 1954 CBS See It Now programs on Senator Joseph McCarthy had made Murrow the image of the fearless, incorruptible journalist.

Edward R. Murrow

Edward R. Murrow in the 1950s. Image source: Golden Globes

In collusion with the police detective leading the case, Mobley's longtime friend Lt. Burt Kaufman (Howard Duff), Mobley hatches a plan. On his newscast, as the camera zooms in for a closeup, he taunts the watching killer (John Barrymore, Jr.) as a "momma's boy" who reads "the so-called comics" (a copy of The Strangler, a lurid comic book in the style of EC's Crime SuspenStories, is left at the scene of the second murder).

Mobley taunts the watching Lipstick Killer

The gay-baiting and comics condemnation are very much of their time; the dual moral panics of the Lavender Scare led by McCarthy and Senator Everett Dirksen, and the anti-comics crusade led by psychologist Frederic Wertham (author of Seduction of the Innocent (1954)), reached their peak around the time of Lang's film. That a figure based on Murrow is using the tactics of McCarthyism is perhaps an unintentional irony. [2]

Cover of Crime SuspenStories No 23 July 1954 depicting a man choking a bathing-suit-clad woman to death in a boat on a lake

Cover of Crime SuspenStories No. 23, July 1954, illustrating the story "Last Resort" by George Evans. Cover artist: George Evans. Image source: CGC Comics

Still on-air, Mobley then announces his engagement to Nancy, setting up his fiancée as bait for the killer. Nancy learns about the scheme only after Mobley's news show; it's confirmed when she sees the pairing of the engagement announcement with the latest Lipstick Killer story on the front page.

Headline reading Lipstick Killer as Mama's Boy adjacent to engagement announcement

"Lipstick Killer as Mama's Boy/ Congratulations: Edward Mobley to wed Nancy Liggett"

With understandable reluctance, and after Mobley points out the plain-clothes detective who will be shadowing her, Nancy agrees to the fait accompli. After all, what could possibly go wrong?

The corruption and injustice of society and the darkness of the psyche were themes Lang had long explored, first in Weimar Germany (Dr. Mabuse, der Spieler (Dr. Mabuse, The Gambler, 1922), Metropolis (1927), Spione (Spies, 1928), and M (1931)) and later continued in his Hollywood films such as You Only Live Once (1937), The Woman in the Window (1944), and his American masterpiece The Big Heat (1953). But the protagonist setting up his fiancée to be attacked by a serial killer is eyebrow-raising even among the grim scenarios of Lang's other films.

At the same time, Lang's direction of While The City Sleeps seemed to me often to lack the distinctiveness of much of his earlier work. The cinematography by Ernest Laszlo, who also shot Impact (1949), D.O.A. (1949), and Kiss Me Deadly (1955), is sometimes flat—though it's hard to tell if it's primarily the fault of the grainy Warner Bros. Archive Collection DVD transfer I watched.

The scenes that bring out the best in Lang and Laszlo are late in the film, as Mobley chases the killer through the deep shadows of the subway tunnels, providing an opportunity for some taut suspense and striking images as trains bear down on the men in the darkness.

Mobley chasing the Lipstick Killer in the subway tunnels

Mobley chases the Lipstick Killer through the subway tunnels.

While The City Sleeps is one of Jonathan Rosenbaum's alternative list of the 100 best American feature films that didn't make the American Film Institute's 1998 list of the 100 greatest American movies. I think there are some other films (and even some other Fritz Lang films) I'd probably put on my alternative 100 list before this one; The Big Heat is a glaring omission on both Rosenbaum's and AFI's lists. But While the City Sleeps is definitely worth watching, especially if you're an Ida Lupino fan—her character is deliciously duplicitous, while remaining fundamentally sympathetic as a woman using her considerable allure to maneuver for power in a man's world.


  1. There was a real "Lipstick Killer" on whom this character was based, who may have killed two adult women and a six-year-old girl in Chicago in late 1945 and early 1946. The murderer used the second victim's lipstick to scrawl a message on the wall of her apartment: "For heavens sake catch me before I kill more I cannot control myself." 17-year-old William Heirens confessed under duress to the killings and was sentenced to three life terms in prison. Characters in the film refer to this real-life case and even quote the "I cannot control myself" message.
  2. Also very much of their time is a work culture where all the women in the newsroom are seen as fair game by the men; every character smokes at any opportunity, indoors or out; and they all pound down alcohol at an alarming rate—we see Mobley in particular get absolutely hammered more than once.